Metal Roof vs Shingles: Factors to Consider When Replacing Your Roof

As a homeowner, are you aware of the crucial differences between a metal and a shingle roof? Today’s metal roofing can mimic the look and feel of asphalt shingles to the point the two are nearly indistinguishable. At Middle Creek Roofing, we educate homeowners on the benefits of choosing a metal roof for their roof replacement.

Metal Roof vs. Asphalt Shingles

Nationally, asphalt shingles remain the most popular form of residential roofing. However, no segment in the roofing industry has emerged faster than metal. Why? Metal roofing systems are highly versatile and long-lasting.

Technological advancements have presented many opportunities for metal, including zinc, copper, and aluminum, to be forged into functional and aesthetically pleasing forms, such as standing seam or corrugated, for residential purposes.

What Are The Advantages Of A Metal Roof?

Why should you strongly consider replacing your existing roof with a metal one? Examine the following benefits:

Extended Longevity

Metal systems offer 2 to 4 times as much service life as other roofing materials, including asphalt shingles. For example, a new metal roof may last between 40 and 80 years, while a standard asphalt shingle roofing system will likely last 20 to 30 years before needing replacement.

Extreme Durability

The typical metal roof offers the highest level of fire protection (Class A). Compared to other roofing materials, such as asphalt shingles, it more easily withstands the harshest Pennsylvania weather conditions, including extreme temperatures, powerful hailstorms, and high winds.

Less Maintenance

Busy homeowners don’t have the time or energy to keep up with the demand of a roof requiring routine upkeep. A metal roof delivers the perfect solution. The average metal roofing system requires almost no maintenance. You won’t need to worry about routinely cleaning or repairing it.

More Energy Efficiency

The price of heating and cooling continues to rise with no end in sight. As a homeowner, how can you manage this expense without breaking the bank? Install a new metal roof. Metal offers the most energy efficiency of any alternative because it reflects sunlight and UV rays.

Understanding the Drawbacks of Asphalt Shingles

While asphalt shingles remain a common choice, they come with notable downsides that homeowners should consider.

Asphalt shingles absorb heat, making them less energy-efficient and causing higher utility bills. Traditional shingles have a significantly shorter lifespan than metal roofing. Frequent exposure to extreme weather causes them to wear out, curl, or crack over time, leading to leaks and costly repairs. Homeowners who opt for shingles often replace their roofs sooner than anticipated because they prematurely degrade.

Another major drawback of asphalt shingles is the level of maintenance they require. Granule loss, algae growth, and water damage are ongoing concerns. After a storm, it’s not uncommon for shingles to be missing or damaged, requiring frequent inspections and repairs. For homeowners seeking a long-term, worry-free roofing solution, asphalt shingles may not be the best fit.

Types of Asphalt Shingles and Their Limitations

Homeowners can choose from three main types of asphalt shingles: three-tab, architectural, and luxury shingles.

Three-tab shingles are the most affordable, but also the least durable, usually lasting only 15-20 years.
Architectural shingles provide better durability and aesthetic appeal but are more expensive.
Luxury shingles mimic the look of slate or wood shakes and offer greater longevity, but they are still susceptible to damage from high winds and hail and cost significantly more than other types of shingles.

Even the highest-quality asphalt shingles cannot match the durability, energy efficiency, or lifespan of a metal roof. Additionally, poor installation practices can lead to significant issues with asphalt shingles. Misaligned shingles, improper sealing, and inadequate ventilation can all shorten a roof’s lifespan and lead to pricey repairs down the line.

Unlike asphalt shingle roofs, metal roofing systems provide a more reliable, long-term solution without the same installation risks.

Metal Roofing: The Smart Investment

When comparing the advantages and disadvantages of roofing materials, metal stands out as the wise choice. It is a more cost-effective investment, and a metal roof lasts decades longer than shingles. It also requires minimal maintenance and delivers superior protection against the elements.

Homeowners looking to enhance their home’s value, improve energy efficiency, and reduce upkeep will find that metal roofing offers the optimal benefits.

Hiring A Qualified Metal Roofing Contractor

Locally owned and operated in Newmanstown, Middle Creek Roofing is the premier Amish roofing company serving Southeastern PA homeowners. We desire to give homeowners the service they deserve. Everything we do is because we care passionately about our customers. If you’d like to know more, please connect with us today.

Request Your Free Estimate

"*" indicates required fields

URL

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Name*

Email*

Phone*

Address*

Service Type*

Hear It Straight From Our Customers

800+ 5-Star Reviews on Google

See what some of our customers have to say about working with Middle Creek Roofing:

      EXCELLENT  
   Based on 872 reviews 
    
 
 
 
   
 
 
       Posted on Google  
   
   Rosa S 
 
 
 
 Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Got a recommendation to go with MCR, we didn’t know our home came without a ridge cap installed, til the rain started coming into the house. These guys were so quick the estimates, returning phone calls and getting the work done. We got a ridge vent and cap replacement. Didn’t need to spend more than what just needed repaired. Will be recommending them to everyone. Will be back in the future for more work. Thank you!
  
 
      Posted on Google  
   
   T J 
 
 
 
 Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. I had an excellent experience with Kyle from Middle Creek Roofing! He arrived early for our appointment, was extremely professional, and took the time to explain everything in great detail. His presentation was thorough, informative, and made the entire process easy to understand. Everything from the appointment to taking my payment was handled quickly and efficiently. Kyle was knowledgeable, personable, and made the whole experience incredibly easy. Awesome customer service from start to finish! I would absolutely recommend Kyle and Middle Creek Roofing!
  
 
      Posted on Google  
   
   Brandon v 
 
 
 
 Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. The entire team at Middle Creek Roofing was phenomenal. They replaced our roof in Lancaster, PA and we could not be more satisfied with the result. Janine made sure we were updated every step of way so we knew exactly what to expect and when to expect it. When the Crew arrived on install day they knew all the details of the project. They were kind, courteous of our surroundings, and very tidy while working. The clean up was flawless. 10/10 I would recommend Middle Creek Roofing for your next roof replacement!
  
 
      Posted on Google  
   
   Tammy H 
 
 
 
 Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. I had shingle replacement done on my home in Newmanstown. Corey and the guys did an amazing job. I recommend middle creek to all my friends and family.
  
 
      Posted on Google  
   
   Jim B 
 
 
 
 Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. We had our house in Harrisburg reschingled by Corey and crew. Great crew ! Made quick work of this job, no one ever stopped! Great looking product!
  
 
      Posted on Google  
   
   Jason 
 
 
 
 Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Pleased with  the asphalt shingle replacement on my home! 40 year shingles look great! Corey and crew came to my house in West Lawn, were very professional and replaced in a timely manner. Would recommend to all my friends and family
  
 
      Posted on Google  
   
   Eugene 
 
 
 
 Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Corey's Crew: This crew is highly skilled and professional. There was a high degree of teamwork and attention to detail. More importantly, the team was very enthusiastic and motivated. The results were impeccable.
  
 
      Posted on Google  
   
   Marie-Aline C 
 
 
 
 Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. House located in Bernville. Received a shingle replacement. They did a great job! They were super professional, very respectful of the property, cleaned up everything afterwards, and I can’t believe how fast they were. The flashing around the chimney and windows looks excellent, and the shingles are lying down the way they’re supposed to! Matt Tilley was our very professional and personable contact person. He got up on the roof and took videos of everything so we could really see what the issues were, and then he explained the whole roofing process really well to us.  He also provided a follow up video so that we could see what the finished product looked like from up on the roof, which was really gratifying and helpful. We are very happy with this company and our new roof!

Why Homeowners Choose Middle Creek Roofing

Superior Customer Service

As a valued customer, your needs come first. We guarantee clear communication, punctuality, and professionalism through every stage of your project.

Quality Products

We use the highest-quality roofing materials from leading manufacturers such as CertainTeed, GAF, Owens Corning, and TAMKO to ensure every repair, replacement, and installation lasts for years to come.

Competitive Warranties

We stand behind our quality products and timeless Amish craftsmanship, which includes the industry’s best manufacturer and labor warranties. We offer 50-year protection on all roofing installations and replacements, plus an extended labor warranty for your peace of mind.

Highly Skilled Roofers

Our roofing team has the training and experience required to handle projects of any size and complexity. We hold all necessary insurance, licensing, and certifications so you’re not liable if any issues arise.